The fake Mac vs. PC price comparison from Microsoft

Hi, i am a PC, so this post should be biased... but it can't be that.

Today, on the official Microsoft Windows blog, there is a strange post:

You can save $3367 if you choose a PC instead of a Mac

What??? Ok, Macs are expensive, but, is possible that there can be a such difference? I can't believe, even if i am a Windows-fanboy

Let's see what comparison they have done:

Mac Mac Price PC PC Price Note
MacBook 999$ Dell Inspiron 15" 699$  
Mac Pro 2500$ Hp d5100t 1049$ Very unfair! You cannot compare a server-grade CPU like a Xeon with a consumer-grade Core2Duo!! Moreover, the Mac pro has 2 physical CPUs
Office 2008 for Mac 149$ No Office 0$ Nothing? PC users will illegally download it?
Quicken for Mac 70$ No Quicken 0$ Quicken??? So useless!
Other software 70$ No extra software 0$ Maybe PC users will download from torrent?
5 years subscription to MobileMe 745$ No subscription 0$ Speechless...
One to One Apple Assistance 99$ No premium assistance 0$ Right...
AppleCare 249$ Standard 3 years Dell warrenty 190$ Well, it is not the same protection...
Update to iLife 09 99$ No iLife 0$ Well, if you buy a new Mac, you don't need to update iLife
Airport Extreme 180$ Normal Router 150$ Well... Macs can also work with a normal router...
Blu-ray reader from Sony 300$ Blu-ray reader from Lite-on 95$ Microsoft, are you playing the fool?
ATI Radeon HD 4870 350$ ATI Radeon HD 4870 260$ The same card, why pay more??
Mac Price (according to Microsoft) 5139$ PC Price (according to Microsoft) 2443$  

Ok, Macs are more expensive, but just a few hundred dollars...

What's wrong:

  1. You cannot compare a normal Pc with a Mac Pro (will you compare a Chevrolet Aveo with a Dodge RAM??)
  2. The 5-years MobileMe subscription (why do that without an iPhone???)
  3. Mac users are buying Office for $149, Pc users does not buy Office for $680 (source)
  4. Mac users chooses all kinds of protection plans, PC users just a basic one

This is like comparing "apples" with oranges!

Why Microsoft did not add to the Mac expenses also an iPhone with a biennal AT&T contract, and an iPod, and other accessories?

Comments